| Year |
All-Conference Selections |
| 1995 |
Cherie Cox, Mary Dominguez, Krissy Ferguson, Katie Hawkins, Anna Loring, Sarah Nicholls |
| 1996 |
Cherie Cox, Krissy Ferguson, Jamie Gantner, Katie Hawkins, Anna Loring, Sarah Nicholls |
| 1997 |
Kristin Brown, Mary Dominguez, Jame Gantner, Sarah Hanlon, Katie Hawkins, Anna Loring, Julianna Hawkins |
| 1998 |
Kristin Brown, Kate Elsen, Jamie Gantner, Julianna Hawkins, Katie Hawkins, Sarah Vandervelde, Amber Wiersema |
| 1999 |
Kristin Brown, Andrea Dearborn, Jamie Gantner, Rebecca Mouw, Katie Shubin, Amber Wiersema |
| 2000 |
Kristin Brown, Padgett Crown, Julianna Hawkins, Sarah Kron, Rebecca Mouw, Katie Shubin |
| 2001 |
Padgett Crown, Jessica Elsen Jenny Fichera, Sarah Kron, Rebecca Mouw, Katie Shubin |
| 2002 |
Jennifer Binger, Emily Parker, Jessica Elsen, Sarah Johnson, Courtney Marcus, Rebecca Mouw, Emily Parker, Laura Rauh, Ashley Vratil |
| 2003 |
Jennifer Binger, Jessica Elsen, Sarah Johnson, Elizabeth Mahon, Brita Nelson, Emily Parker, Laura Rauh, Hannah Tan |
| 2004 |
Bethany Barton, Jennifer Binger, Jessica Elsen, Sarah Johnson, Laura Koontz, Colleen McAndrews, Brita Nelson, Laura Rauh, Ashley Wiersema |
| 2005 |
Jennifer Binger, Kira Davis, Erin Hodina, Kari Klynstra, Laura Koontz, Colleen McAndrews, Sarah Richardson |
| 2006 |
Bethany Barton, Kira Davis, Maria Della Torre, Kristin Eggert, Kari Klynstra, Laura Koontz, Taryne Lee, Sarah Richardson |
| 2007 |
Bethany Barton, Kira Davis, Maria Della Torre, Kristin Eggert, Kelly Foltz, Kari Klynstra, Taryne Lee, Sarah Richardson |
| 2008 |
Maria Della Torre, Kelly Foltz, Kari Klynstra, Ali Kopelman, Taryne Lee, Laurn Lindner, Jaime Orewiler |
| 2009 |
Lauren Anderson, Brittany Bergh, Maria Della Torre, Ali Kopelman, Taryne Lee, Jaime Orewiler |
| 2010 |
Brittany Bergh, Amanda Brait, Laura Karsten, Katelyn Kishkunas, Ali Kopelman, Kaitlyn Le Baudour, Jaime Orewiler |
| 2011 |
Laura Karsten, Katelyn Kishkunas, Ali Kopelman, Kaitlyn Le Baudour, Val Lelle, Jaime Orewiler, Anna Seabolt, Erin Strom |
| 2012 |
Amanda Brait, Leah DeMoss, Laura Karsten, Keri Shannon, Alexa Sharkey, Ally Witt |
| 2013 |
Amanda Brait, Leah DeMoss, Sarah Guidera, Alexa Sharkey, Sydney Sharkey, Annie Wooldridge |
| 2014 |
Megan Campbell, Sarah Frey, Kelsey Graham, Sarah Guidera, Alexa Sharkey, Sydney Sharkey, Ally Witt |
| 2015 |
Sam Frank, Madison Peebles, Kristin Rauh, Sydney Sharkey, Sarah Van Wingerden, Ally Witt, Annie Wooldridge |
| 2016 |
Kathryn McGregor, Madison Peebles, Mary Pettit, Molly Thorson |
| 2017 |
Kathryn McGregor, Isabelle Oliver, Madison Peebles, Sarah Tomich, Sarah Van Wingerden, Morgan Whitman |
| 2018 |
Aeva Graber, Madison Peebles, Sarah Tomich, Nicole Wright |
| 2019 |
Sara Bakke, Carney Blake, Lauren Ketchum, Izzy McNally, Sarah Tomich |
| 2021 |
Mia Blair, Lauren Ketchum, Izzy McNally, Audrey Sexson, Morgan Beamer, Grace Hermanson, Tori Seeland |
| 2022 |
Lauren Ketchum, Sarah Max, Audrey Sexson, Myah Schoolman |
| 2023 |
Morgan Beamer, Mia Blair, Audrey Sexson, Katherine Ashley |
| 2024 |
Mia Blair, Grace Crowder, Emily Setran |
